CommunityDevOps ExchangePartners
10 minutes

Declarative vs Imperative Programming for Infrastructure as Code (IaC)

Written by
Team Copado
Table of contents

Infrastructure as Code, or IaC, is a DevOps practice that involves turning your infrastructure configurations into software scripts. This allows you to automatically provision and patch new resources, which saves time and leads to fewer configuration mistakes. IaC tools use either a declarative or imperative programming language to execute configuration scripts. Let’s define these two programming paradigms before comparing declarative vs imperative programming for DevOps infrastructure as code so you can see the advantages and disadvantages of each.

Declarative Programming for IaC: Defining What

In declarative programming, you specify the name and properties of the infrastructure resources you wish to provision, and then the IaC tool figures out how to achieve that end result on its own. You declare to your IaC tool what you want, but not how to get there. Some examples of popular IaC tools that use the declarative programming paradigm include Terraform, Puppet, Ansible, Salt, and CloudFormation.

Imperative Programming for IaC: Defining How

In imperative programming, you specify a list of steps the IaC tool should follow to provision a new resource. You tell your IaC tool how to create each environment using a sequence of command imperatives. Chef is a popular imperative IaC tool, and both Ansible and Salt have some support for imperative programming as well.

Declarative vs Imperative Programming

When you compare declarative vs imperative programming, you’ll find that each paradigm comes with advantages and disadvantages that you need to consider before choosing your approach to IaC.

Pros and Cons of Declarative Programming

Declarative programming is a popular approach to infrastructure as code. You define the desired end-state of the final configuration and the IaC solution figures out how to get there. Declarative programming is highly idempotent, or repeatable, which means you can execute your IaC commands over and over again and still achieve the same result. The declarative paradigm also adapts well to configuration drift – the inevitable, slow changes to your infrastructure over time – because the IaC tool’s provisioning steps are not explicitly defined.

The biggest drawback of the declarative approach is that you give up a lot of control over the individual steps in the provisioning process. It’s also not the best choice for small fixes and updates that can be handled by a simple CLI (command line interface) script – declarative programming can overcomplicate matters and slow down the process.  

Pros and Cons of Imperative Programming

Imperative programming, on the other hand, requires more scripting knowledge because you must write commands for every provisioning step. This gives you control over how you accomplish infrastructure tasks, which is ideal when you need to make small changes, optimize for a specific purpose, or account for software quirks.

The biggest initial challenge to the imperative approach is that it requires a high level of skill with the programming language, which infrastructure teams in the initial stages of the DevOps journey may not have yet. Imperative IaC scripts are often less idempotent as well — your predefined steps can lead to different results depending on the environment. Plus, imperative IaC scripts are so explicit that an error with one step can cause the whole thing to fail. 

Declarative vs Imperative Programming Comparison:

  Declarative Programming Advantages

Imperative Programming Advantages

Requires less coding skill

Control over every step of the process

Highly repeatable

Ideal for simple or one-off tasks

Adapts well to configuration drift

Follows a familiar, step-by-step approach

Declarative Programming Disadvantages

Imperative Programming Disadvantages

Less control over the process

Requires a lot of programming knowledge

Can overcomplicate simple tasks

Less idempotent

May be harder to conceptualize

Explicitness makes it error-prone


Overall, many organizations seeking to fully automate and orchestrate their DevOps infrastructure prefer the declarative approach. You can use declarative IaC tools to create highly repeatable and adaptable configuration scripts without years of coding experience. However, if you’re easing into infrastructure automation with a few CLI scripts, or you don’t need a full orchestration platform, the imperative approach is often simpler and easier to manage.

Comparing declarative vs imperative programming for IaC is just one step in the DevOps infrastructure automation process.



Book a demo

About The Author

#1 DevOps Platform for Salesforce

We build unstoppable teams by equipping DevOps professionals with the platform, tools and training they need to make release days obsolete. Work smarter, not longer.

Building a Scalable Governance Framework for Sustainable Value
Copado Launches Copado Explorer to Simplify and Streamline Testing on Salesforce
Exploring Top Cloud Automation Testing Tools
Master Salesforce DevOps with Copado Robotic Testing
Exploratory Testing vs. Automated Testing: Finding the Right Balance
A Guide to Salesforce Source Control
A Guide to DevOps Branching Strategies
Family Time vs. Mobile App Release Days: Can Test Automation Help Us Have Both?
How to Resolve Salesforce Merge Conflicts: A Guide
Copado Expands Beta Access to CopadoGPT for All Customers, Revolutionizing SaaS DevOps with AI
Is Mobile Test Automation Unnecessarily Hard? A Guide to Simplify Mobile Test Automation
From Silos to Streamlined Development: Tarun’s Tale of DevOps Success
Simplified Scaling: 10 Ways to Grow Your Salesforce Development Practice
What is Salesforce Incident Management?
What Is Automated Salesforce Testing? Choosing the Right Automation Tool for Salesforce
Copado Appoints Seasoned Sales Executive Bob Grewal to Chief Revenue Officer
Business Benefits of DevOps: A Guide
Copado Brings Generative AI to Its DevOps Platform to Improve Software Development for Enterprise SaaS
Celebrating 10 Years of Copado: A Decade of DevOps Evolution and Growth
Copado Celebrates 10 Years of DevOps for Enterprise SaaS Solutions
5 Reasons Why Copado = Less Divorces for Developers
What is DevOps? Build a Successful DevOps Ecosystem with Copado’s Best Practices
Scaling App Development While Meeting Security Standards
5 Data Deploy Features You Don’t Want to Miss
Top 5 Reasons I Choose Copado for Salesforce Development
How to Elevate Customer Experiences with Automated Testing
Getting Started With Value Stream Maps
Copado and nCino Partner to Provide Proven DevOps Tools for Financial Institutions
Unlocking Success with Copado: Mission-Critical Tools for Developers
How Automated Testing Enables DevOps Efficiency
How to Keep Salesforce Sandboxes in Sync
How to Switch from Manual to Automated Testing with Robotic Testing
Best Practices to Prevent Merge Conflicts with Copado 1 Platform
Software Bugs: The Three Causes of Programming Errors
How Does Copado Solve Release Readiness Roadblocks?
Why I Choose Copado Robotic Testing for my Test Automation
How to schedule a Function and Job Template in DevOps: A Step-by-Step Guide
Delivering Quality nCino Experiences with Automated Deployments and Testing
Best Practices Matter for Accelerated Salesforce Release Management
Maximize Your Code Quality, Security and performance with Copado Salesforce Code Analyzer
Upgrade Your Test Automation Game: The Benefits of Switching from Selenium to a More Advanced Platform
Three Takeaways From Copa Community Day
Cloud Native Applications: 5 Characteristics to Look for in the Right Tools
Using Salesforce nCino Architecture for Best Testing Results
How To Develop A Salesforce Testing Strategy For Your Enterprise
What Is Multi Cloud: Key Use Cases and Benefits for Enterprise Settings
5 Steps to Building a Salesforce Center of Excellence for Government Agencies
Salesforce UI testing: Benefits to Staying on Top of Updates
Benefits of UI Test Automation and Why You Should Care
Types of Salesforce Testing and When To Use Them
Copado + DataColada: Enabling CI/CD for Developers Across APAC
What is Salesforce API Testing and It Why Should Be Automated
Machine Learning Models: Adapting Data Patterns With Copado For AI Test Automation
Automated Testing Benefits: The Case For As Little Manual Testing As Possible
Beyond Selenium: Low Code Testing To Maximize Speed and Quality
UI Testing Best Practices: From Implementation to Automation
How Agile Test Automation Helps You Develop Better and Faster
Salesforce Test Cases: Knowing When to Test
DevOps Quality Assurance: Major Pitfalls and Challenges
11 Characteristics of Advanced Persistent Threats (APTs) That Set Them Apart
7 Key Compliance Regulations Relating to Data Storage
7 Ways Digital Transformation Consulting Revolutionizes Your Business
6 Top Cloud Security Trends
API Management Best Practices
Applying a Zero Trust Infrastructure in Kubernetes
Building a Data Pipeline Architecture Based on Best Practices Brings the Biggest Rewards
CI/CD Methodology vs. CI/CD Mentality: How to Meet Your Workflow Goals
DevOps to DevSecOps: How to Build Security into the Development Lifecycle
DevSecOps vs Agile: It’s Not Either/Or
How to Create a Digital Transformation Roadmap to Success
Infrastructure As Code: Overcome the Barriers to Effective Network Automation
Leveraging Compliance Automation Tools to Mitigate Risk
Moving Forward with These CI/CD Best Practices
Top 3 Data Compliance Challenges of Tomorrow and the Solutions You Need Today
Top 6 Cloud Security Management Policies and Procedures to Protect Your Business
What are the Benefits of Principle of Least Privilege (POLP) for My Organization?
You Can’t Measure What You Can’t See: Getting to know the 4 Metrics of Software Delivery Performance
How the Public Sector Can Continue to Accelerate Modernization
Building an Automated Test Framework to Streamline Deployments
How To Implement a Compliance Testing Methodology To Exceed Your Objectives
Cloud Security: Advantages and Disadvantages to Accessibility
Copado Collaborates with IBM to Accelerate Digital Transformation Projects on the Salesforce Platform
Continuous Quality: The missing link to DevOps maturity
Why Empowering Your Salesforce CoE is Essential for Maximizing ROI
Value Stream Management: The Future of DevOps at Scale is Here